
Transcription
Faster than Fast—Oracle IntroducesExadata X9M PortfolioWhy Oracle’s New Exadata, ExaC@C, and ZDLRA X9M Innovations Topple theCompetition While Giving Customers up to 80% More Performance at the Same PriceQ3 2021DANIEL NEWMANSHELLY KRAMERRON WESTFALLFounding Partner Principal AnalystFounding Partner Lead AnalystSenior Analyst Research DirectorPublished: September 2021IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
Table of Contents3 Introduction4 Executive Summary5 Exadata Architecture and Software:Key to Performance and Latency Breakthroughs6 Exadata X9M: Delivering Throughput and Efficiency Advances7Exadata X9M: Increasing Consolidation and Cost Benefits8 ExaC@C X9M: Meeting the Need for Data Sovereignty with a CloudDatabase Service in Customer Data Centers10 Autonomous Database on ExaC@C X9M:Lowering Costs with a Self-driving Database11 Recovery Appliance X9M Enhancements:Strengthening Oracle Database Protection12 Conclusion and RecommendationsFASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO2
IntroductionOracle Debuts New Exadata, ExaC@C, and ZDLRA X9M Solutions that Solve theTopmost Customer Database ProblemsDatabase (DB) customers must deal with frequently recurring problems due to major underlyingissues that require innovative breakthroughs to resolve. These underlying issues include low IOPS(Input Output Operations Per Second) which reduce application performance when data workloadsincrease, high latency that slows transactions reducing productivity and customer satisfaction,and low throughput that impedes the efficient processing of large amounts of data for analyticsapplications. Customers identify additional underlying issues such as low availability, little to noconvergence of enterprise DB and infrastructure assets, lack of cloud identicality preventingseamless movement between on-premises and public cloud resources, insufficient automation, andpoor utilization efficiency directly driving up DB costs, resulting in ever more problems that requireattention. In sum, the scaling of DB size and performance is a topmost concern across the entire DBecosystem.In our evaluation of Oracle’s new Exadata X9M portfolio, it is clear the company’s vision directlyaddresses the underlying issues that cause database administrators and IT decision makers to losesleep: the constant battling of DB problems. The Exadata X9M portfolio is an unbeatable value prop,providing extreme performance, lowest cost, and is available everywhere. The platform deliverswhat we see as best-in-class DB hardware. It scales-out elastically and provides DB-optimizedcomputing, networking, and storage capabilities. The Exadata portfolio also offers DB-aware systemsoftware, which uses specific algorithms designed to vastly improve the execution of OLTP (OnlineTransaction Processing), OLAP (Online Analytical Processing), and DB workload consolidation. Wealso note that automated management is applied across the entire portfolio to reduce typical DBadministration or even eliminate manual management completely. Lastly, we’ll note that thesecapabilities are identically assimilated throughout all on-premises, Exadata Cloud@Customer(ExaC@C), and Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) Exadata offerings.Following our evaluation, we view the Oracle Exadata portfolio as well-suited for fulfilling theworkload demands of enterprises, including the mission critical, high-volume DBs of Fortune Global100 organizations. These workloads include scaling petabyte warehouses, assuring ultra-fast OLTP,complex business applications (e.g., SAP, Oracle Siebel, E-Business Suite, etc.), and massive DBconsolidation.The new Exadata X9M portfolio which includes Oracle Exadata Database Machine X9M, ExaC@CX9M, and Zero Data Loss Recovery Appliance X9M can easily meet the topmost concerns anddemands of DB customers globally. In examining the new Exadata X9M portfolio proposition, weanalyze the following elements: Exadata Architecture and Software: Key to Performance and Latency Breakthroughs Exadata X9M: Delivering Throughput and Efficiency Advances Exadata X9M: IncreasingConsolidation and Cost Benefits ExaC@C X9M: Meeting the Need for Data Sovereignty with a Cloud Database Service Autonomous Database on ExaC@C X9M: Lowering Costs with a Self-driving Database Recovery Appliance X9M: Strengthening Oracle Database ProtectionFASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO3
Executive Summary Oracle’s new Exadata X9M solution delivers substantial improvements over the Exadata X8Mand can give customers an enduring competitive edge. Oracle Exadata X9M directly addressesgrowing IT and DB decision maker demands for accelerating analytics and increasing DBconsolidation through the support of Intel Ice Lake 32-core CPUs in DB servers that deliver 33%more cores for parallel analytics and 64% more memory bandwidth. Exadata X9M enhancements prioritize increasing scale and consolidation efficiency. HighCapacity and Extended Storage Servers now provide 28% more storage capacity by using 18TBdisks instead of 14TB disks at the same price to keep up with expanding database sizes. Oracle has ensured that all Exadata X9M enhancements are uniformly applied to its ExadataCloud@Customer (ExaC@C) X9M solution, fulfilling organizations’ growing demands forcloud benefits for databses and workloads that they cannot move to the public cloud due tosovereignty laws, industry regulations, organizational policies, security policies, network latency,or complexity of migrating interdependent databases and applications to a new environment. By running Autonomous Database (ADB) on ExaC@C X9M, with the solution providing dedicated,secure resources, fully automated management, and cost-conscious automatic scaling of DBconsumption pricing, Oracle notably broadens the Exadata X9M solution’s addressable market. Additional enhancements to ExaC@C X9M incorporate backup to Oracle’s Zero Data LossRecovery Appliance (Recovery Appliance), which protect and archive data in customer DCs andAutonomous Data Guard, which enables a new service with streamlined setup and management.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO4
Exadata Architecture and Software:Key to Performance and Latency BreakthroughsA review of Oracle’s Exadata architecture and software approach provides the foundation fordiscerning why Oracle’s new Exadata X9M solution delivers substantial improvements over theExadata X8M and can give customers an enduring competitive edge. For starters, Oracle’s ExadataSmart Scan technology has been enhanced to efficiently support more complex queries in the mostdemanding workloads. Smart Scan now shares metadata across storage servers to increase parallelquery execution, substantially improving DB scalability in data-intensive environments. Factor infaster decryption algorithms for all Exadata storage server generations and smarter managementusing enhanced DB alerting and faster software updates, and the DB fundamentals are in place forsignificant Exadata X9M IOPS and throughput improvements while maintaining the eye-catching 19microsecond SQL read latency of the previous generation X8M solutions.Exadata X9M supports the latest Intel Ice Lake 32-core CPUs (Central Processing Units) that enable33% more cores for OLTP in comparison to Exadata X8M. PCIe 4.0 dual-port active-active 100GbRoCE (Remote Direct Memory Access over Converged Ethernet) and up to 2TB of memory per DBserver allow customers to increase the impact of OLTP caching, key ingredients that enable ExadataX9M to deliver up to 27.6M read IOPS per rack and scale DB performance as racks are added. Whenyou sum all this up, each rack can support a mix of up to 1,216 DB cores, 38TB memory, 3.8 PB RawDisk, 920 TB NVMe (Non-Volatile Memory express) Flash, and 27 TB Intel Optane PMem (PersistentMemory) so organizations can create configurations that cost-effectively meet their current needsas well as adapt and grow to meet changing requirements.From our perspective, the combined Exadata X9M capabilities deliver unprecedented OLTP DBperformance and cost compared to Exadata X8M. These breakthrough metrics include: 72% more IOPS: Enabling new transactional and hybrid DB use cases. 42% lower costs per IOPs: Making Exadata capabilities more affordable for manyorganizations. 33% more pooled resources: Increasing consolidation rates and resource utilizationefficiency.We see the combined advances in IOPS, costs, and resourcing pooling efficiency as vital topowering the DB innovations that are key to removing the underlying causes of DB problemscustomers face, as well as providing Oracle with the portfolio differentiation needed to expand theExadata X9M solution’s market share against both cloud on-premises and conventional on-premisesvendors. Exadata is also a data warehousing powerhouse and rival Snowflake has no on-premisesdata warehouse offering for example, which means even more opportunities to win new businessfor Oracle with the X9M generation.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO5
Exadata X9M:Delivering Throughput and Efficiency AdvancesIn today’s data center and cloud environments, accelerating analytics and increasing consolidationare top priorities for IT and DB decision makers. Oracle Exadata X9M directly addresses thesedemands through the support of Intel Ice Lake 32-core CPUs in DB servers that deliver 33%more cores for parallel analytics and 64% more memory bandwidth. PCIe 4.0 flash cache inExadata storage servers enable 80% faster throughput which combine with enhanced automaticcolumnarization of data using vector processing formats in flash cache to deliver over 1 TB/secondof scan throughput for advanced analytics and in-database machine learning algorithms.The Exadata X9M’s use of two active 100 GB/sec RoCE networking connections on each DBand storage server increases throughput between them by 80%, significantly accelerating theaccumulation of scan results generated on storage servers on the DB servers and any subsequentprocessing. Taken together, these new enhancements deliver what we see as significant net newbenefits in the following areas compared to Exadata X8M: 87% higher throughput: Enables new data-intensive use cases. 47% lower scan costs: Brings Exadata capabilities to more customers. Expanded, swifter pooled resources: Enables improved real-time analytics inside OLTPapplications.When compared to Oracle Exadata X9M’s scale out architecture with massive parallelism, legacydo-it-yourself infrastructures that connect DB servers to block storage devices over FibreChannelare severely limited in terms of the latency, IOPS, and throughput they can deliver. All raw data inthese legacy environments must be shipped from the storage devices back to the DB servers forprocessing as opposed to Exadata’s approach of initially processing the data where it resides – onthe storage servers. We see Oracle Exadata X9M’s integrated architecture with massive parallelism,rapid PCIe flash, and the offloading of data-intensive operations to storage as delivering thethroughput and efficiency that organizations are looking for today to meet data-intensive analyticalrequirements.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO6
Exadata X9M: Increasing Consolidation and Cost BenefitsExadata X9M enhancements also prioritize increasing scale and consolidation efficiency. HighCapacity and Extended Storage Servers now provide 28% more storage capacity by using 18TB disksinstead of 14TB disks at the same price to keep up with expanding database sizes and enable moredatabases to be consolidated on an Exadata single system. The previously mentioned 33% increasein database server CPU cores and memory coupled with the use of all-flash storage in those serverssupport more VMs per DB server which also increases the level of database consolidation thatcustomers can achieve. Also, Oracle Database’s converged DB capabilities allow customers to runany mix of OLTP, analytics, graph, spatial, and machine learning databases on the same system,further increasing the impact of DB consolidation.By combining these features, it’s obvious that Oracle is endeavoring to dramatically improve the costeffectiveness of its DB machine proposition. These cost improvements compared to Exadata X8Minclude: 42% less cost for OLTP IOPS & 47% less cost for analytics scans. More work per DB CPU: Reduces infrastructure size and license costs. Broader pooled resources: Increases DB and infrastructure consolidation resulting in loweroperational costs.By using Exadata X9M, organizations achieve definitive DB consolidation gains, avoiding theoperational risks and costs of managing and securing information on multiple platforms.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO7
ExaC@C X9M: Meeting the Need for Data Sovereignty witha Cloud Database Service in Customer Data CentersOracle has ensured that all Exadata X9M enhancements are uniformly applied to its Exadata Cloud@Customer (ExaC@C) X9M solution, fulfilling organizations’ growing demands for cloud benefits forDBs and workloads that they cannot move to the public cloud due to sovereignty laws, industryregulations, organizational policies, security policies, network latency, or complexity of migratinginterdependent databases and applications to a new environment. As an Oracle-managed service,Oracle Cloud operators access ExaC@C for maintenance. To further meet tight regulationsin industries such as financial services, Oracle provides operator access control that allows ITorganizations to control when Oracle Cloud operators can access systems, for how long, andwhat they can do while there with real-time session monitoring, logging, and session terminationcapabilities.With Exadata Cloud@Customer X9M, organizations can, at any time and without taking thedatabases offline, increase the amount of DB server resources that they consume to meet peakdaily or seasonal requirements or reduce them to control costs. This significantly reduces cloudconsumption costs because IT teams no longer need to overprovision resources to meet peakdemands for applications that cannot permit up to 30 minutes of downtime every time anunderlying compute shape is changed.The Exadata Cloud@Customer X9M enhancements axiomatically include Intel Ice Lake 32-coreCPUs in DB servers, Intel Ice Lake 24-core CPUs in storage servers, 28% more storage capacity(compared to ExaC@C X8M), 1.5TB DRAM per DB server, and the same 19 microseconds latencywith PMem and RoCE. We like the fact that these enhanced capabilities are all available at the sametime as Exadata X9M, while maintaining the same price as the ExaC@C X8M offering.As a result, customers gain immediate benefits in relation to ExaC@C X8M, such as up to 22.4M IOPS(an 87% boost), 540 GB/sec throughput (80% more), and 992 vCPUs worth of database compute(24% more). We view these capabilities as providing clear differentiation of the ExaC@C X9Msolution in relation to AWS Outposts with RDS (Relational Database Service). For example, Oracle’sminimum SQL read latency is 19 microseconds while RDS on AWS Outposts is a much lengthier1,000 microseconds, giving Oracle a fifty-fold advantage when accessing data. The ExaC@Csolution delivers 540 GB/S maximum throughput while RDS on AWS Output is limited to only 28.5GB/S, yielding Oracle an eighteen-fold throughput edge. Moreover, Oracle’s ExaC@C supportsonline scaling with no application downtime, no downtime for maintenance and upgrades, andapplication-transparent DB acceleration with PMem, whereas the RDS on AWS Output solution lacksall these functions and, as a result, is orders of magnitude slower.Whereas Oracle Exadata Cloud@Customer is a strategic offering for Oracle, it’s not clear that otheron-premises cloud offerings such as AWS Outposts and Azure Stack are more than a checkbox forthose vendors.In further examining the area of DB functionality, we observe that Oracle ExaC@C X9M offers SQLoffload to up to 576 cores in intelligent storage servers. In contrast, AWS Outposts with RDS offersno intelligent storage capabilities and only limited operator access control. Moreover, we surmiseFASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO8
RDS on AWS Outposts supports only MySQL, PostgreSQL, and SQL Server functions, but does notfor Redshift, Aurora, DynamoDB, Document DB (Mongo DB), Keyspaces (Cassandra), Neptune(Graph), and Timestream (Time series) – or Oracle Database, whereas Oracle Database’s convergeddatabase capabilities meets these customer needs.Oracle ExaC@C X9M fulfills the top priority demands of customers who require and decide toimplement public cloud infrastructure with managed cloud database services in their data centers.These customer fulfillment benefits compared to ExaC@C X8M include: Up to 80% faster throughput and 87% higher IOPS: The dual improvements can run anydatabase workload faster or reduce costs of running those workloads by up to 47%. Elastic storage expansion: Up to 45% lower infrastructure costs for data-intensive workloads. Operator Access Control: Increases security in regulated settings.Oracle Exadata Cloud@Customer X9M allows organizations to deploy industry-leading databaseperformance in their data centers, enabling them to run applications faster while lowering costs andmaintaining full control of their data to meet data sovereignty and security requirements. We seeOracle ExaC@C X9M attaining clear competitive differentiation against AWS RDS on AWS Outpostsacross key performance and capabilities categories, further enhancing the complete Exadataproposition.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO9
Autonomous Database on ExaC@C X9M:Lowering Costs with a Self-driving DatabaseIt appears that Oracle is further broadening the addressable market of the Exadata X9M portfolioby running Autonomous Database (ADB) on ExaC@C X9M, with the solution providing dedicated,secure resources, fully automated management, and cost-conscious automatic scaling ofDB consumption pricing. The Autonomous DB capabilities encompass Oracle’s AutonomousTransaction Processing and Autonomous Data Warehouse cloud services and provide machinelearning based automatic scaling, tuning, patching, and securing of the database along with AutoMLenhanced analytics and other Autonomous-only capabilities.This is particularly important for organizations looking to adopt Autonomous Database, as thecomprehensive set of autonomous capabilities assures customers that maximum performance isattainable, full data sovereignty is safeguarded, and the built-in auto-scaling of DB consumptionreduces the cost of running databases in all scenarios.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO10
Recovery Appliance X9M Enhancements:Strengthening Oracle Database ProtectionAdditional enhancements to ExaC@C X9M incorporate backup to Oracle’s Zero Data Loss RecoveryAppliance (Recovery Appliance), which protect and archive data in customer DCs and AutonomousData Guard, which enables a new service with streamlined setup and management. In addition,Oracle DB Shared Server provides the Use Shared Server feature for legacy apps to reduceconnection counts and customer managed keys with OKV single instance that simplifies encryptionkey management.In addition, Oracle’s next generation Recovery Appliance X9M delivers a 30% increase in backupcapacity by replacing the 14 TB drives found in ZDLRA X8M systems with 18TB drives, allowingorganizations to protect more DBs with longer retention periods with a “Base rack” configurationproviding 207TB of physical capacity, 2PB effective backups, and 15TB/hour restore rates. A “Fullrack” configuration supports more than 1 PB physical capacity, 13 PB of effective backups, and a24TB/hour restore rate. Recovery Appliance X9M also lowers the solution’s entry price by up to50% for Base rack configurations resulting in substantially lower per-Terabyte cost for protecteddatabases since all configurations are created by starting with the Base rack. This new entry priceexpands the addressable market for Recovery Appliance to medium and smaller-sized organizationsAdditional enhancements to ExaC@C X9M incorporate backup to Oracle’s Zero Data Loss RecoveryAppliance (Recovery Appliance), which protect and archive data in customer DCs and AutonomousData Guard, which enables a new service with streamlined setup and management. In addition,Oracle DB Shared Server provides the Use Shared Server feature for legacy apps to reduceconnection counts and customer managed keys with OKV single instance that simplifies encryptionkey management.In addition, Oracle’s next generation Recovery Appliance X9M delivers a 30% increase in backupcapacity by replacing the 14 TB drives found in ZDLRA X8M systems with 18TB drives, allowingorganizations to protect more DBs with longer retention periods with a “Base rack” configurationproviding 207TB of physical capacity, 2PB effective backups, and 15TB/hour restore rates. A “Fullrack” configuration supports more than 1 PB physical capacity, 13 PB of effective backups, and a24TB/hour restore rate. Recovery Appliance X9M also lowers the solution’s entry price by up to50% for Base rack configurations resulting in substantially lower per-Terabyte cost for protecteddatabases since all configurations are created by starting with the Base rack. This new entry priceexpands the addressable market for Recovery Appliance to medium and smaller-sized organizationsFASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO11
Conclusion and RecommendationsIn summary, we believe the new Exadata X9M integrated solution delivers higher performance anda broader range of capabilities across all Oracle DB workloads than anything else in the marketthat runs on-premises—be it a cloud on-premises or a typical server, ensuring that customers gainsignificantly more value. In the area of performance, Exadata X9M provides the 19 microsecondlatency, increased OLTP IOPS, accelerated analytics throughput—orders of magnitude faster thanAWS Outposts and Azure Stack—and enhanced Smart Scan capabilities that DB and IT decisionmakers prioritize.For enhanced software requirements, customers can use Autonomous Database on ExaC@C X9M,operator access control, enhanced notifications, faster decryption, and faster updates, all of whichare vital to meeting fast-evolving customer administration and security demands. Finally, the newsolution lowers TCO by allowing customers to achieve higher levels of consolidation, use lessinfrastructure, reduce database license requirements, lower costs across key metrics, and achieveoperational and consumption savings that are valued in all DC environments—all at the same priceas the previous X8M generation. That’s significantly more bang for the customer’s buck.The overall Exadata X9M proposition directly addresses the underlying issues that cause the mostproblems and disruption for DB customers. The Oracle X9M furnishes the scale-out hardware,DB-aware software intelligence, automated management capabilities, and architectural identicalitythat make the new solution worthy of top consideration in the successful transformation of DBtechnology across all environments. Running Oracle Database on anything other than an X9M is thefunctional equivalent of trying to put a Tesla operating system in a Dodge Hellcat—it’ll operate indegraded mode and it’s far too advanced for the underlying, aging hardware to handle.DB Decision Makers Must Consider Oracle Exadata X9M. DB decision makers must consider thenew Oracle X9M solution, since it provides the superior architecture, enhanced software, and elasticscaling of DB resources that are essential to ensuring top performance and lowering TCO within anyDB environment.DB and IT Decision Makers Considering AWS RDS on Outposts or Azure Stack Must Look atExaC@C X9M. DB decision makers should compare the complexity, costs, and lack of functionalityand performance when considering RDS on AWS Outposts. We identify Oracle ExaC@C X9M ashaving a definite competitive edge especially in areas like minimum SQL read latency, maximum SQLthroughput, and crucial areas of cloud database functionality such as supporting online scaling withno application downtime and avoiding downtime for maintenance and upgrades.Evaluate Autonomous Database on ExaC@C Credentials. DB administrators and decision makersneed to consider the ability to blend Autonomous Database, Exadata X9M, and OCI automation,security, and economics into one package by running Autonomous Database on ExaC@C X9M. Thisincludes mitigating human errors with autonomous operations and providing comprehensive datasovereignty and low-latency application-tier connectivity in customer DCs. No other vendor canmatch this combination and Exadata is strategic for Oracle and a core enabler for their substantialcloud progress.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO12
Important Information About This PaperCONTRIBUTORS:Daniel NewmanFounding Partner Principal Analyst, FuturumResearchShelly KramerFounding Partner Lead Analyst, Futurum ResearchRon WestfallResearch Director Senior AnalystPUBLISHERS:Daniel NewmanFounding Partner Principal Analyst, FuturumResearchShelly KramerFounding Partner Senior Analyst, FuturumResearchINQUIRIES: Contact us if you would like to discussthis report and Futurum Research will respondpromptly.DISCLOSURES: This paper was commissionedby Oracle. Futurum Research provides research,analysis, advising, and consulting to many high-techcompanies, including those mentioned in this paper.No employees at the firm hold any equity positionswith any companies cited in this document.ABOUT ORACLEOracle offers integrated suites of applications plussecure, autonomous infrastructure in the OracleCloud. For more information about Oracle (NYSE:ORCL), please visit us at oracle.com.ABOUT FUTURUM RESEARCHFuturum is an independent research, analysis,andadvisory firm, focused on digital innovation andmarket-disrupting technologies and trends. Everyday our analysts, researchers, and advisors helpbusiness leaders from around the world anticipatetectonic shifts in their industries and leveragedisruptive innovation to either gain or maintain acompetitive advantage in their markets. Read ourdisclaimer statement here.CITATIONS: This paper can be cited by accreditedpress and analysts, but must be cited in-context,displaying author’s name, author’s title, and “FuturumResearch.” Non-press and non-analysts must receiveprior written permission by Futurum Research for anycitations.LICENSING: This document, including anysupporting materials, is owned by Futurum Research.This publication may not be reproduced, distributed,or shared in any form without the prior writtenpermission of Futurum Research.CONTACT INFORMATIONFuturum Research, LLC I futurumresearch.com I 817-480-3038 I [email protected]: @FuturumResearch 2021 Futurum Research. Company and product names are used for informational purposes only and may be trademarks of their respective owners.FASTER THAN FAST—ORACLE INTRODUCES EXADATA X9M PORTFOLIO13
A review of Oracle’s Exadata architecture and software approach provides the foundation for discerning why Oracle’s new Exadata X9M solution delivers substantial improvements over the Exadata X